What Is the Most Unhealthy Candy?

Identifying the most unhealthy candy, you'd find treats like Butterfinger, Baby Ruth, and Hershey's Take 5 bars topping the list due to their high levels of sugar, fat, and additives. For instance, Hershey's Take 5 bars pack nearly half the daily recommended fat intake for women and include ingredients many try to avoid, like high fructose corn syrup and oils. Meanwhile, candies like Nerds and Sour Patch Kids lead with staggering sugar contents, making portion control essential. As you explore further, you'll discover tips and insights to enjoy your sweets responsibly without overindulging.

Key Takeaways

  • Hershey's Take 5 bars are high in fats, additives, and calories, making them one of the most unhealthy candies.
  • Nerds have the highest sugar content with 93g per 100g, contributing to their unhealthy status.
  • Butterfinger, Baby Ruth, and 3 Musketeers have high levels of sugar and fat, positioning them as less healthy candy options.
  • Candy Corn's significant sugar content, with 23g in just a 30g serving, showcases its unhealthy nature.
  • The consumption of candies like Starburst and Twizzlers should be moderated due to their high sugar content per serving.

Unveiling the Culprits

What's lurking in your candy bowl that makes some treats far more treacherous than others? As Halloween approaches, it's important to recognize the culprits behind those tempting, colorful wrappers. The most unhealthy candies, including Butterfinger, Baby Ruth, and 3 Musketeers, are packed with high levels of sugar and fat, making them less than ideal for anyone's sweet tooth. These candies, alongside classics like M&Ms, boast significant sugar content per serving, pushing them to the top of the list when it comes to unhealthy options.

Starburst, for instance, contains a staggering 33 grams of sugar in just one serving, easily surpassing the daily recommended sugar intake. Similarly, Twizzlers, although often marketed as a low-fat option, are high in sugar, with six pieces nibbling away half of your daily sugar allotment. And don't be fooled by the seemingly healthier choice of Peanut M&Ms; a regular package serves up 250 calories and enough sugar to meet—or exceed—a woman's daily recommendation. These candies, laden with sugar and high fructose corn syrup, transform your Halloween treat bowl into a minefield of unhealthy choices.

Sugar Content Showdown

Delving into the sugar content showdown, you'll find Nerds leading the pack with a whopping 93g of sugar per 100g. This staggering amount sets the bar high, or should we say sweet, for candy lovers seeking the ultimate sugar rush. With a serving size recommended at just 15g due to its high sugar content, it's no wonder Nerds have captured the sweet tooth of many, packing 14g of sugar in each serving.

Following closely in this sugary race are Sour Patch Kids, which rank second with an impressive 80g of sugar per 100g. Despite their mouth-puckering sour start, these candies quickly turn sweet, contributing significantly to their sugar content. Swedish Fish, Candy Corn, and Skittles aren't far behind, boasting 77g, 74g, and 73g of sugar per 100g, respectively. Specifically, a 30g serving of Candy Corn contains a remarkable 23g of sugar, highlighting the importance of moderation when indulging in these treats.

This sugar content showdown underscores the necessity of paying attention to serving sizes when enjoying your favorite candies. Whether it's the tartness of Nerds or the chewy sweetness of Swedish Fish, the sugar content in these popular candies can quickly add up, making serving size an essential factor in your candy consumption.

Calorie Counter Alert

While sugar content is a key factor in determining a candy's health impact, calorie content also plays a notable role in how unhealthy a candy can be. When considering the calorie content of popular candies, it's evident that some are notably higher in calories, contributing to their unhealthy status.

For instance, the 3 Musketeers bar tops the list with a whopping 190 calories per serving, making it a less favorable choice for those monitoring their calorie intake. Similarly, M&Ms match this high calorie count with 190 calories per serving, further solidifying its classification among the most unhealthy candies based on calorie content.

Butterfinger and Baby Ruth aren't far behind, each containing 170 calories per serving. This high calorie content contributes directly to their unhealthy status, pushing them towards the top of the list of candies to consume sparingly. Additionally, the Milky Way candy bar, with 160 calories per serving, also falls into the category of being high in calories.

These examples illustrate that while candies are often critiqued for their sugar content, their calorie content is equally important in determining their overall unhealthy classification.

Fat and Additives Analysis

Hershey's Take 5 candy bars' composition, rich in fats and additives, greatly contributes to their ranking as the most unhealthy candy. With five layers of fat, including chocolate, pretzels, peanut butter, caramel, and peanuts, Hershey's Take 5 bars aren't just high in sugar but also loaded with a significant amount of fat. One serving packs nearly half the daily recommended fat intake for women, emphasizing the bars' fat content dilemma. The grams of fat, combined with high fructose corn syrup, oils, flavoring agents, and preservatives, make these candy bars a challenge for anyone trying to manage their weight.

Moreover, the amount of sugar and the presence of artificial ingredients in Hershey's Take 5 bars accentuate their unhealthy profile. As a beloved Halloween candy, it's easy to underestimate the calorie punch these bars deliver. Enjoying them post-physical activity might help offset their calorie-dense nature, but it's essential to stay mindful of their fat and additives. Hershey's Take 5 bars embody the quintessence of what many try to avoid in their diet, making them an indulgence that demands moderation.

Portion Control Tips

To manage your candy intake effectively, consider using smaller bowls or plates to help control portion sizes. This simple change can trick your brain into feeling satisfied with less, as the size of your dish plays a critical role in how much you consume. When indulging in your favorite sweets, it's important to be mindful of the serving sizes listed on the packaging. These guidelines are there to help you regulate your intake and maintain a balance.

Dividing larger candy bars into smaller portions is another effective strategy for portion control. By doing this, you're not only able to satisfy your cravings but also prevent the temptation of overeating. Opting for individually wrapped candies can further help limit consumption, as it adds an extra step before indulging, encouraging mindfulness and self-control.

Practicing self-control and moderation is key to enjoying treats without overdoing it. Remember, smaller portions and being conscious of serving sizes can make a significant difference in how you enjoy candy. By following these portion control tips, you can indulge in your sweet treats without compromising your health goals.

Healthier Alternatives

After mastering portion control, it's also important to explore healthier candy options that don't sacrifice flavor for nutrition. Consider candies like Smarties, Tootsie Pops, Sour Patch Kids, and Airheads, which are known for their low-calorie and low-sugar profiles. Each of these options offers a different experience regarding taste and texture, but they all share a common benefit: a lower amount of fat and sugar compared to many other candies on the market.

For instance, Laffy Taffy, with its chewy texture, contains only 2g of total fat per serving, making it a choice with less fat. On the other hand, chocolate lovers might find it hard to resist traditional bars like Milky Way or Butterfinger, but it's important to note that these come with a higher calorie, sugar, and fat content.

Opting for candy-coated chocolates like M&Ms might seem like a compromise, but even one serving size of these colorful treats packs 7g of total fat and 26g of sugar, highlighting the importance of looking for low fat and saturated fat options. Remember, even one fun size piece can add up, so choosing candies with reduced sugar and fat content can make a significant difference regarding your overall intake.


You've navigated through the sweet maze, uncovering the not-so-sweet truths.

The crown for the most unhealthy candy? It's a tight competition, but one shocking statistic stands out: some candies pack in over 30 grams of sugar per serving—that's about 7.5 teaspoons!

Remember, moderation is key. Don't deprive yourself of the occasional treat, but maybe opt for those healthier alternatives or keep an eye on portion sizes.

Your body (and dentist) will thank you.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.